The Reuben at the Rebooted New York Sub Isn’t Traditional, but it Is Delicious
Andrew Kelley drapes slices of white cheese over soft submarine rolls. He’s behind the counter, as usual, constructing sandwiches alongside co-owner (and his wife) Edi Kelley. After loading the pillowy bread with rounds of cheese, he looks up. “Do you want a Reuben? I could make you a Reuben,” he…